(04-06-2015, 01:29 PM)anagogy Wrote: Basically, the argument has been offered that the only reason Ra brought up eating meat was, allegedly, because it was just Ra catering to Carla's belief or desire surrounding meat.
Yeah, pretty much.
(04-06-2015, 01:29 PM)anagogy Wrote: I think that's an extremely illogical conclusion.
I'll repost what I said to Monica earlier in the thread because it is the same essential question, rephrased in a different way:
If it was my custom to lie, would Ra then incorporate the advice of lying into my behavior if I asked advice on how to better my situation in life? Or if it was my custom to murder humans (and furthermore believed it was the right thing to do, lets say I thought I was protecting my people by performing some kind of sacrifice (i'm thinking of tribal ancient humans)) would they incorporate that into advice about someone? Would they not say anything? To respect or cater to my free will decisions/beliefs? I sincerely doubt that. These actions would not be consonant with the Law of One.
You are illustrating bias here. You say those actions wouldn't be consonant with the Law of One? Why not?
(04-06-2015, 01:29 PM)anagogy Wrote: Animal abuse, and eating meat are two *separate* things.
It is impossible to eat meat without abusing the animal. Killing a sentient entity is the ultimate abuse.
(04-06-2015, 01:29 PM)anagogy Wrote: Correlation does not equal causation. It is naive to think eating meat and animal abuse are synonymous. It is the constant anthropomorphization of animals. They are different than us. Not lesser, not better, but different. Yes, they have emotions, yes they have minds, yes they see the world differently than you, just as minerals see the world different from us, and fourth density beings see the world differently than us.
Their desire to live isn't different. Their capacity to feel pain and fear is exactly the same as ours.
(04-06-2015, 01:29 PM)anagogy Wrote: And there can be compassion in using animals for food, too. To actually think that a transformation to spirit in as painless and quick a way as possible by a skilled hunter is inherently worse than slowly dying in the wild, by disease, or because it got so old it's teeth fell out and it slowly starved to death, is naive at best, and deliberately ignorant at worst.
Carnivorous animals take care of old and diseased animals. They don't need us to help them with that.
Furthermore, carnivorous animals hunt the old and diseased prey; whereas, human hunters tend to go after the biggest trophy, thus weakening the herd.
Humans have upset the balance of Nature.