02-29-2012, 05:13 PM
(02-29-2012, 03:30 PM)Diana Wrote:(02-29-2012, 03:06 PM)Ali Quadir Wrote: People often don't even recognize this fact...
I see what you are pointing out. I am female, so as a male, could you rephrase my supposition from a more balanced perspective? (By the way, I did say that females allowed the suppression, which is half of the equation, and releases "blame.")
Let's not ignore the fact, however, that we have been male-dominated societies (for the most part) for a very long time. This is not an accusation. And just because you are male now, and I am female, does not mean that we haven't participated on both sides.
How about we phrase it such that both males and females have been placed in a position where they were not able to be truly themselves. So that natural relationships to the other gender were impossible?
A male dominated society means a society in which a certain type of male and a certain type of female fit really well. If you didn't fit in the straightjacket either as a male or a female you were in trouble..
Obviously this was a worse time for women. I don't think we need to steal each others thunder. But I think we both suffered... We might occasionally joke about it but no mature man today really wants to go back to those times. Imagine true lovers a guy and a girl perfect for each other.. Yet they're continually pushed into ritualized behavior towards each other. Not just by society but primarily by their own beliefs.
We're still not in the clear though. Male and female energies are not perfectly balanced. Though we've come a long way.
(02-29-2012, 03:36 PM)Bring4th_Monica Wrote:Not in general but when it comes to the evolution of our psyches... Yes I do. Less time passed so it will have had less effect on the hard wired and thus more intrinsic qualities of male or female psychology... For other parts of our psychology, the last few millenia will be more important. But in this case with deeply rooted archetypes I'd look back over a long time, not just (cosmically speaking) last week...(02-29-2012, 03:06 PM)Ali Quadir Wrote: Whats important is how things where much further back.Are you suggesting that the more recent history is less important?
Quote:If so, I disagree. I think it's all important, but if anything, the more recent history is a better reflection of where we're at now. We have to take into consideration that humans have been evolving (presumably).Under normal circumstances I would agree. But the artificial roles imposed upon men and women do not allow us to consider much of the recent history to be considered normal circumstances...
The 7000 years or so that civilisation existed will obviously have made some changes in mankind, I'm not denying the importance of that period. But something as essential as the relation between the sexes is very deeply rooted. We cannot understand it by only looking at the last period.. We have to go back a long time.
Quote:(02-29-2012, 03:06 PM)Ali Quadir Wrote: *I* held the same beliefs and values. So I don't hold any blame. I merely hope to show that these beliefs are so common that we hardly see them any more.
Respectfully, Ali, you're beginning to sound condescending. I've already told you that you have misunderstood me. To continue to insist that I think a certain way, when I already told you I don't and tried to better explain my position, is both laughable and insulting.
I'll let it go then.. Call it what you want, I quoted you on all counts. But if you did not mean any of it like you appear to me to have written it. Then I'll just have to accept that.
Let me rephrase my position... I think men and women evolved over hundreds of thousands of years, into a creature that is intrinsically pretty balanced. Men and women are two halves of a circle, they fit each other perfectly.
Then came an influence be it the paternalistic religions or whatever that caused us as a species to have completely inappropriate images about our genders. This resulted in what apparently is a male dominated society. In reality it wasn't the males dominating. It was these paternalistic ideas dominating, because most males fitted as poorly as most females.
Then there was the sexual revolutions. Where women regained a large part of their lost identity.. Men regained a bit of theirs... But girls were the big winners...
These days there's still a large body of inappropriate gender bias. Much hidden bias is oriented towards males. Without wanting to reject or reduce the bias that still exists for women. I have to note that many men have some difficulty in self image when it comes to their masculinity.
Maybe it's similar to just before the sexual revolutions where men would often betray hidden bias by things they said, even if they consciously, agreed with and supported the womens movement. It's just so deeply rooted.
If you start paying attention to the bias towards men in our society then you discover there's really an awefull lot of it. While people who are not paying attention to it are able to blatantly deny it.